I’ve written several posts recently about balancing complexity and student skill. But how do you change the level of complexity?
Add Strange Restrictions
- Tiny Time limits. Take a task that has become simple, give a time limit, and complexity increases. On the other hand, give more time to reduce complexity.
- Very Short Lengths. 140 characters, or 10 words, or three sentences, etc. Interestingly, this can both increase and decrease complexity: advanced students must cram their ideas into a small space, while struggling students have less content to produce.
- Reduce Resources. Sometimes a strange set of tools produces an interesting result. This could mean limiting research materials, writing tools, electronics, writing surfaces, size of paper, type of paper, etc. Once, my 6th graders had to write an essay on kindergarten paper. You can bet this changed their approach to writing.
Note that these restrictions parallel what you see in shows like Top Chef, Project Runway, of Chopped. Take a group of experts and give them unexpected limits. The results are often incredible feats of creativity.
Restrictions Change Expectations
In all of these cases, let your class know your expectations change because of these restrictions.
If the time limit is five minutes, you don’t expect the same results as if students had a week. If they’re limited to writing on a notecard, the expectation is not the same as if they had a computer to type on. The point is for students to see what they can do with the restriction.
Complicate The Content
From the tools of Depth and Complexity:
- Dig into the ethical issues of an idea. The pros and cons. What’s good and what’s bad? A previously dry topic might come to life with ambiguity and conflict.
- Explore multiple perspectives: what would _ think about this? It gets even more interesting if this new perspective is a bit of a surprise. What would George Washington think of Ancient China? How would Juliet, from Romeo and Juliet judge Hermione Granger?
- Change over time: What was this idea like in the past? How will it be in the future? How have people’s views towards it changed?
Examples of these tools in action:
- Alexander The Great writes a tweet critiquing or praising Napoleon’s leadership.
- Compare and contrast a success or a problem in the U.S., looking at 1776 versus 1812. Write your response as a haiku.
- Create a scripted conversation between The Boy in The Giving Tree and Brian from Hatchet. One character must give the other advice about their main problem. You have ten minutes. GO!
And finally:
- As mentioned in this article, adding an adult’s presence can both increase and decrease complexity.
Photo by Fliter Forge